FDIC Study Released on Bank Overdrafts

The FDIC has just released the "FDIC Study of Bank Overdraft Programs." Here are a few of the more interesting findings"

• Customers with 5 or more NSF transactions accrued 93.4 percent of the total NSF fees reported for the 12-month period. Customers with 10 or more NSF transactions accrued 84 percent of the reported fees. Customer accounts with 20 or more NSF transactions accrued over 68 percent of the reported fees.
• Customer accounts with 1 to 4 NSF transactions were charged $64 per year in NSF fees on average. Customer accounts with 5 to 9 NSF transactions were charged $215 per year in NFS fees on average. Customer accounts with 10 to 19 NSF transactions were charged $451 per year in NFS fees on average. Customer accounts with 20 or more NSF transactions were charged $1,610 per year in NSF fees on average.
• Almost half (48.8 percent) of all reported NSF transactions took place at POS/debit (41.0 percent) and ATM (7.8 percent) terminals. Checks accounted for 30.2 percent of the reported NSF transactions.
• Assuming a $27 overdraft fee (the survey median), a customer repaying a $20 POS/debit overdraft in two weeks would incur an APR of 3,520 percent; a customer repaying a $60 ATM overdraft in two weeks would incur an APR of 1,173 percent; and a customer repaying a $66 check overdraft in two weeks would incur an APR of 1,067 percent. More rapid repayment of the overdraft amount results in higher APRs, and slower repayment results in lower APRs.
• Accounts held by young adults (ages 18 to 25) were the most likely among all age groups to have automated overdraft NSF activity. Among young adult accounts, 46.4 percent incurred NSF activity, compared with 12.2 percent of accounts held by seniors (over age 62) and 31.9 percent of accounts held by other adults. Nearly 15 percent of accounts held by young adults recorded more than ten NSF transactions during the year, compared with 12.1 percent of adult accounts and 3.0 percent of senior accounts. Most NSF transactions made by young adult accounts (61.7 percent) originated at a POS/debit terminal.

Almost half of the non-sufficient funds (NSF) withdrawals were by young adults using debit cards. No doubt most of these were honest mistakes from not keeping track of accounts. Given the electronic network that exists it would be easy for banks to notify users of insufficient funds at the point of sale. Having been notified, most would have chosen not to incur the overdraft fee. However, given the enormous fees these transactions generate, the banks seem to have little incentive for notifying account holders of a potential overdraft. They make the fees charged by payday lenders look good.